The attacker may have the advantage of a five- or 10-yard run on you, so he's in the air first, which means he gets to the ball first. Reaching in also re… In fact, it was one of the best and most understanding midfield partnerships the game has seen. In this example above, LAFC is in possession with minimal pressure on the player with the ball. It seems like we are edging away from it slightly with the development of the suffoco, but what Spain and Barcelona do simply cannot be regarded as man marking. It works man to man where he can see if someone isn’t picked up but zonal doesn’t work like that. Therefore, as the two San Jose centre-backs begin to get tight to their marks the are creating space in behind for attacking players to run into. As the title says, what do you do? The ability to maintain their organisation really is a direct result of the Earthquakes two holding midfielders. As a result, he sees his right-back being closed down and, with no other options, again decides for the longer dumped pass. in which San Jose excels at, most of the time. This is certainly an unfavourable position for the Eastrthqaukes which ultimately results in a goal for LAFC. The tactical weaknesses, in turn, are also at hand. Live marking gobbles up time and it is very challenging to get around a whole class within the confines of a lesson. Man marking in open play is a strange, fluid concept. Gerard Houllier would utilise the guarding of zones when managing Liverpool, and it backfired so often it made you wonder where the merits lay. This can create numerical disadvantages for the defending team. High up the field, San Jose has committed numbers to press in an attempt to win back possession. Ronnie Dog Media Comm. Whether it’s defending from set-pieces or open play, the defenders chase down the opposing players they are marking, not allowing them even an inch of space. Many Variations – There are many different ways to run your man-to-man defense depending on the team you’re playing against and what the strengths and weaknesses of your team are. Internet speed difference: MAN cannot work on traditional phone copper wires. Of the 3 teams yet to concede a goal from a corner in the Premier League (Man City, Arsenal and Bournemouth) two normally use Zonal and the other man marking. Their ability to cut off passing angles and stay tight to their man marks gives the LAFC centre-back only one option, which is to play a long pass forward in an attempt to not give the ball away in a dangerous position. Constant organization and communication are what allow the Earthquakes to maintain their shape and begin their pressing high up the pitch. Create . From the first corner of the game, you pick your man and mark him from then on to avoid confusion. This requires great stamina, top match fitness and picking a player to mark right from the very start of the game. In man-marking, a player sticks very tight to an opponent, oftentimes even tracking just the one opponent. With zonal marking you can choke the team, make them move to a certain direction and control … Pavement marking tapes also have some disadvantages: high initial cost and not suitable for old roads in poor conditions. Your other hand should be in the passing lane. The marking at set pieces and in open play are two completely separate entities and evolve independent of each other. In truth, this debate only ever surfaces when a team concedes a goal from a corner kick, but the ideologies stretch much further than set pieces. It is also a direct result of utilising a 4-2-3-1, allowing them to press with more players higher up the field. When posed with the question of how to defend corners, Benitez is a man with a fixed belief: zonal marking. This is clearly the outcome Almeyda is hoping for and a situation his team are well equipped to deal with as situations such as this are consistent when San Jose is defending. This increases overall installation and management costs. This causes you to lose your balance and defensive stance, and you become easy for the offensive player to get around. the vocal keeper is misleading in zonal marking. In the modern game, this is harder to pull off as players move more freely and are more similar athletically. This longer pass allows San Jose to adjust while the ball is in the air and win back possession. By almost all accounts, zonal marking in set pieces is a disaster waiting to happen. The disadvantage of man marking is that whoever your best headers of the ball are marking will run to the near or far post and thereby drag them away from the centre of the goal, which is the critical position and where you would rather have them. Showing that perhaps late in the season the players were unable to maintain the level Almeyda’s system required. This tactical analysis will highlight the strengths and weaknesses of Almeyda’s defensive man-marking system with an in-depth examination of this tactical theory. They spread out evenly and divided the pitch between them. The reason is it often results in players leaving their own marked player to cover for someone who has been beaten on the dribble creating big holes on the field. Also refer advantages and disadvantages of LAN (Local Area Network)>> andWAN (Wide Area Net… Due to their man-marking system, attacking midfielder Andrés Rios of the Earthquakes is able to cut out the pass and regain possession of the ball. Moving away from set pieces, you'll see a large number of teams employing zonal marking in the open field. Having an organised and prepared backline, San Jose was able to win the ball and begin their own possession again. Again placing a defender in 1v1 situation with minimal or no cover and proving difficult to manage. Dunga's Brazil in the 2010 World Cup were the epitome of territorial defence, using a two-man pivot in Gilberto Silva and Felipe Melo to screen the back four. This can stretch from sticking to a player for free kicks and corners, all the way through to doggedly chasing one player for a full 90 minutes. While it did not directly result in goal this opportunity is created from a lack of organisation and awareness from the San Jose backline. Within the idea of overcommitting comes the high stepping of the San Jose centre-backs who regularly look to cut out passes to players in half-spaces. The first is that regularly places a team in 1v1 defensive situations all over the field. Major League Soccer 2019: New York City VS Portland Timbers – tactical analysis, MLS 2020/2021: DC United vs Montreal Impact – tactical analysis, MLS 2020 – New York City FC v New York Red Bulls – Tactical Analysis, MLS 2020/2021: Toronto FC vs Inter Miami – tactical analysis. How are you supposed to beat your opponent in the air when he's already hurtling toward you? Keep the palm of your lead hand facing up. In a way, it’s a compromise between position-oriented zonal marking and man-marking. Creating fewer opportunities to provide cover for teammates which can result in large gaps of space being created for attacking teams. This is due to a security problem and other extra configuration. Man to man marking is when each player picks up a player and stays on that player for most of the game . In this sequence, we see the centre forward trying to cut out a pass to the Timbers right centre-back. It was likely not the end result Almeyda would’ve wanted, but it was still an improvement from the year prior which had the Earthquakes finishing with, Perhaps the most influential difference between those two seasons was Almeyda and his philosophy. Players hesitate and remain unsure whose responsibility it is, and that's when the opposition usually pounces. It places more pressure on the ball increasing the chance of a mistake on the opponents part. Following are the disadvantages of MAN: ➨It is difficult to manage the network once it becomes large. However, the danger with using a pure man-marking system is that it will inevitably affect the attacking play because the focus of the team shifts to ensuring that the opposition doesn’t score. The most important tactics in Almeyda’s man-marking system are constant organization and awareness both areas in which San Jose excels at, most of the time. Disadvantages of metropolitan area network (MAN) Difficult to manage: If MAN becomes bigger then it becomes difficult to manage it. The formation used by a team may dictate whether or not to use zonal marking. Furthermore, problems arise when the ball drops between the zones. If it doesn't, don't worry about it. Jose Mourinho's latest attempt to topple Barcelona in El Clasico saw Sami Khedira and Xabi Alonso form one of the finest holding duos since the aforementioned Brazilians. Whereas marks help students identify their exact scores, grades place students in predefined categories such as A and B. Therefore, some growing pains are to be expected. Marking is employed all over the pitch, with or without possession, and varies greatly with regard to circumstances. Perhaps the most common issue comes when opponents have possession and both San Jose centre-backs are marking a player in their defensive half. Still, the most interesting aspect of Almeyda’s system is the roles of his centre-backs. MLS Playoffs 2020: New England Revolution vs. Orlando City SC- tactical... MLS playoffs 2020: Nashville SC vs Inter Miami – tactical analysis, MLS 2020: Columbus Crew vs Atlanta United – tactical analysis. It is becoming more common for teams to use aspects of each system, and its success depends as much on the execution as the method used. Here we see once beyond the right-back San Jose is unable to provide any cover out wide and as a result, LAFC is able to attack down the left side of the field. Most opt for man, some for zonal. Because it has been heavily replaced by zonal marking, the man to man marking system is far too predictable, and it makes it hard to deal with certain threats. They never rushed forward to retain the ball and nearly always stayed within 15 yards of each other. This organisation is key especially when the Earthquakes are unable to press and as a result, must defend in their own half. What Spain do, when out of possession, is just out-and-out rushing. V. // Emiel Hertecantlaan 19a 9290 Berlare - Belgium // BTW (VAT) BE 0693988181. There is no guarantee a man-marking system would have prevented both goals but had Koscielny been able to get touch tight to Dawson he may well … If the ball enters your zone, get rid of it. Still, the Earthquake centre-backs are not the only San Jose players who get caught overcommitting. Sometimes I find myself armed with a pen circling tables just to get everyone’s books marked before the bell rings. Under the marking system, even if two students are of similar calibre, one can ace out the other by a fraction of a point. However, even when they are able to do so, teams have discovered ways to break them down. To effectively defend this situation both the outside-backs of San Jose must step in line with the centre-backs otherwise they leave attacking players onside. Football analyst and enthusiast. This level of assessment encourages competitiveness. Modern-day world football managers are split into two decisive camps when it comes to defending and marking. I heard Steve Bruce on MOTD say For set pieces you want to zonal mark and also man mark, but If its not a set play then man mark also zonal mark at the same time Other managers say different, but what Steve Bruce said … As laser systems, and fiber lasers in particular, offer so much control, a range of depths can be achieved to suit the user. As a result of the LAFC centre-forward is able to receive the ball and strike a first-time shot which ends up in the back of the net. This gap allows the Timbers to begin their attack down the middle of the field with minimal pressure on the ball. Disadvantages of man-marking Man-marking innately includes several disadvantageous factors in football. Their ability to press teams high up the pitch for the entire 90 minutes was key in their success. Still, at times this contributes to their success as it doesn’t allow players to sit in the half-spaces between the San Jose midfield and defensive lines. The ability to do so give the LAFC player less time on the ball and therefore less time to make a decision. As he is late and aiming to be man-marking a quick tough from the LAFC midfielder puts him beyond the right-back. ➨Network installation requires skilled technicians and networkadministrators. Here again, we see Florian Jungwirth stepping to Carlos Vela of LAFC a former. The 2010 FIFA World Cup shifted world football towards territorial play and the emphasis of playing in relation to another. The main problem is that zones become blurred, players hesitate, and second balls are often converted to goals. Disadvantages of zonal marking – It can be more complicated to deliver the zonal system to players as each player has a job to do. © Copyright 2019 - Ronnie Dog Media All Rights Reserved. They ended the year without a playoff berth and a record of 13 wins, 12 losses, and 9 ties under newly appointed manager Matías Almeyda in his first year as boss. Other examples are plentiful. Man marking in open play is a strange, fluid concept. The Cons of Live Marking 1. This typically comes down to the spine of the team and, in the Earthquakes case, heavily relies on its two holding midfielders and centre backs. It's a relatively aggressive way of defending, pitting one man's physicality against another. Always zonal marking.Zonal marking has always appeared a strange foreign idea to the British and during the 350 games that “Rafa” took charge of Liverpool for, the English media would jump on this ‘wr… It is for this reason that the slow or weak can be outgunned. The vast majority of managers employ this style, spending hours on the training ground perfecting it and pairing players to track each other's runs. As a result of this Timbers holding midfielder on the ball is able to dribble past him into a massive area of space. Likely, the most isolated players in this system are the outside backs. Atletico Madrid, whilst facing Athletic Bilbao in last year's UEFA Europa League final, dropped into an impregnable wall of five to block midfield through-balls. In zonal marking, a player must cover the space around his position, loosely moving his position to any nearby opponent and staying close to them. If you're facing six top-tier aerial players and don't have six to combat them, opting to man-mark them could see you concede easy goals. Ultimately, while a small detail the inability of the San Jose attacking players to press correctly created this massive gap an attacking opportunity for Portland. Your best three defenders can move to pick up their opponent's most dangerous scorers, leaving the rest to sort themselves out. Slide with your opponent, and try to get him/her to stop the dribble, and then close in and apply pressure. Man-to-man marking is the strategy where defenders are assigned one specific person to tail throughout the game. Disadvantages of man-marking. So where's the distinction between man marking and high-line pressing? Even at times stepping past their holding midfielders which is unique to Almeyda’s style of play. Man marking is the de facto best way to defend a set piece, whether it's a corner, a close-range free kick or a punt into the penalty area from 45 yards. The problem with man marking is that it can actually be quite simple for opposition attackers to take advantage of. It’s the system that leaks goals. Here we see Florian Jungwirth the left-sided Earthquake centre-back stepping to apply pressure on the ball. If MAN is installed on copper wires then there will be very low speed. The ball is then played over the top and creates a decent opportunity for LAFC. Both the marking system and the grading system have their pros and cons. Disadvantages Of Marking System. This is in large part due to the positioning of Earthquakes 4-2-3-1 formation. Creating fewer opportunities to provide cover for teammates which can result in large gaps of space being created for attacking teams. This picture provides a great example of the effectiveness of this high pressure. San Jose pushes five, sometimes even six, players into their opponents half in an attempt to either win the ball or force long balls for centre backs and defenders to cut out. It was likely not the end result Almeyda would’ve wanted, but it was still an improvement from the year prior which had the Earthquakes finishing with 4 wins, 21 losses, and 9 ties which put them in 12th place in the Western Conference. One of the clearest aspects of Almeyda’s philosophy is seen in how regularly the Earthquakes look to get pressure on the ball immediately even in their opponents half. It is also a direct result of utilising a 4-2-3-1, allowing them to press with more players higher up the field. Zonal is about each man being alive to the situation. Ultimately, Almeyda will be looking to resolve some of the mentioned innate weaknesses of his man-marking system. In man-marking, players are assigned opponents and they are expected to track their player and make sure they beat them to the first ball. Rather than stick to a player, you guard a certain zone. A modern interpretation of this is the revelation of the "suffoco"—a traditional midfield destroyer positioned higher up the pitch. Overall the ability of San Jose to remain organised as a defensive unit and stay tight to players is what makes this system a success. But man marking defensive strategy did have the disadvantage that it made football matches ultra-defensive. While it is a transition here we see a covering centre-back for San Jose 1v1 with a massive gap between him and his partner. In this particular man-marking system, the Earthquakes centre-backs will regularly step high up into the midfield to stay with their mark. The two factors limit the application of marking tapes. Teams playing 4–4–2 usually operate a zonal marking system, but teams playing a sweeper do not. In the above sequence, the San Jose right-back is attempting to get tight to his mark as he receives the ball. If you continue to use this site we will assume that you are happy with it. In the picture above we see a great example of their ability to stay organised defending in their own half. These 6 scenarios comprise a list of 6 different teachers and the marking system each employs. ➨It requires more cables for connection from one place to the other compare to LAN. Laser marking is one of many laser processes, and each has been invented, and subsequently widely adopted, with a unique array of benefits. It is worthwhile to note it was the first year for both the manager and system in San Jose. And because the rest of the group is marking individual players it causes significant problems for San Jose defensively. Every player needs to learn man-to-man defensive principles – It’s crucial that all youth players develop good man-to-man habits and understand man-to-man defensive principles. ➨It is difficult to make the system secure from hackers andindustrial espionage. Let's take a closer look at both approaches and determine which, if either, is more effective. In this particular sequence, the right-back for San Jose is lower than the rest of the backline keeping the LAFC attacking player onsides. The Watford 1st goal – he could be vocal as fuck but it wouldn’t stop the runner finding the space and scoring from 5 yards. In this sequence, his ability to apply the pressure forces the LAFC player to play backwards. In this particular sequence, the key was to get pressure on the ball immediately. In England, it’s not uncommon to hear the saying that “Zonal marking is not defending.” But, what the fact that these pundits often ignore is that goals are scored even when defenders are man marking. Here again, we see Florian Jungwirth stepping to Carlos Vela of LAFC a former EPL and Arsenal player. Man-to-man defense is a type of defensive tactic used in team sports such as American football, association football, basketball, and netball, in which each player is assigned to defend and follow the movements of a single player on offense.Often, a player guards his counterpart (e.g. Unfortunately for San Jose and Almeyda, these situations occurred regularly in 2019. This also provides a great visual of this man-marking system where we see each Earthquake player marked to their Portland Timber opponent. A former Argentinian national team player, Almeyda utilises a defensive man-marking system which paid dividends for the Earthquakes early in 2019. CTRL + SPACE for auto-complete. Brighton's short ball causes issues (Image: Wyscout) While it does allow wingers to press higher up the field it also leaves their outside backs 1v1 for the majority of the match. The modern game is so fluid that it's almost impossible—or perhaps inadvisable—to utilise strict man marking to the scale of 10 players. Don't "reach-in". This sequence ultimately results in another quality attacking chance coming from another Earthquake player overcommitting in their man-for-man pressure. It’s not that man marking is the be all and end all of defending. This gap is too big to close for the Earthquakes left-back. This can give the attackers a better chance to make clean contact. While all processes work similarly, using a laser beam, this laser beam can be manipulated in multiple ways to achieve varied desired effects. Choose any 2 of the scenarios and list the advantages and disadvantages of each. The traditional tussle at a corner will never die, but how teams organise themselves on the pitch is an ever-changing concept. It is most commonly employed with regard to one specific player, rather than an entire team, as closely marking one dangerous … It is time-consuming. Still, towards the end of the campaign teams such as LAFC were able to find those dent in the San Jose armour. Reply Here San Jose has committed five players into the LAFC half. Due to the man-marking system, several Earthquake players are forced to follow their marks who immediately recognize the hole and begin to sprint towards the San Jose goal. In open play, however, the zonal game rules supreme. This typically comes down to the spine of the team and, in the Earthquakes case, heavily relies on its two holding midfielders and centre backs. Unlike laser marking, a process which engraving is similar to, the aim here is to remove a portion of the material being worked with. Man-to-Man What it is: Pretty self-explanatory, defenders are assigned a player on offense (wide receivers, tight ends, backs) and their goal is to try and prevent them from catching/progressing with the ball. We use cookies to ensure that we give you the best experience on our website. Rafa Benitez’s regime at Liverpool was one of many highlights, not least the Champions League win against AC Milan (2005). Write CSS OR LESS and hit save. center guarding center), but a player may be assigned to guard a different position. Zonal marking is more difficult when defending set pieces such as free kicks and corners, and most teams change to man marking in these situations. Zonal marking is usually more difficult in set-piece situations and so many teams revert to man-marking. Tactical Theory: San Jose Earthquakes man-marking defence, The San Jose Earthquakes finished the 2018/19, under newly appointed manager Matías Almeyda in his first year as boss. The San Jose Earthquakes finished the 2018/19 Major League Soccer season in eighth place in the western conference. The advantage over man-marking is The first is that regularly places a team in 1v1 defensive situations all over the field. The objective is to stay close to your man and stop him from scoring or making a telling impact upon the game. San Jose pushes five, sometimes even six, players into their opponents half in an attempt to either win the ball or force long balls for centre backs and defenders to cut out. Collective man-marking. Every player must know their job and do their job. It is most commonly employed with regard to one specific player, rather than an entire team, as closely marking one dangerous opposition player can negate the threat they pose. The advantages of rigid man-marking are also clear: simplicity, no communication problems when passing and moving, no special tactical training, playing off an ideally superior athleticism, and a continuous focus on the opposition’s key player. It comes with certifiable advantages, as you can effectively pick your matchups before the game starts. Each defender is assigned a player to mark. Putting LAFC up just 5 minutes into the match. Constant organization and communication are what allow the Earthquakes to maintain their shape and begin their pressing high up the pitch. Unfortunately, stepping higher up the field to Vela creates a massive hole between the other Earthquakes centre-back and left-back. For me it means that man-marking is unacceptable against highly mobile and technically gifted teams such as Barcelona and Arsenal, because a player like Messi will just drag your defenders out of their zone while his teammates tear you apart(Messi is at the Right Inside Fwd position, drags your left defender with him to the middle and passes to Dani Alves, who is free to do whatever he wants, … Make social videos in an instant: use custom templates to tell the right story for your business. Marouane Fellaini has been used in this role against Manchester United, as have Ivan Rakitic against Real Madrid and Mario Mandzukic against Andrea Pirlo over the last several months. Also, identify the approximate weight that is to be placed on each part of the system. It's not man-focused, it's ball-focused. Italian teams in the 60s and 70s perfected this tact… the player generaly marks their player so tight they can touch the player. Both Jackson Yueill and Aníbal Godoy defensively cover a significant portion of the field and are constantly organising their teammates. Currently earning a Master's degree in Sport and Exercise Science. In open play, many teams will drop into a predefined shape when out of possession to cover equal areas of the pitch. – You can leave attackers unmarked potentially allowing them to get a running jump for the ball. A former Argentinian national team player, Almeyda utilises a defensive. In this sequence, the tight defensive man-for-man marking tactics caused the Timbers significant problems going forward. If the attacking team can bunch together, along with the defenders, then it makes it simpler for one of them to run around the back of the group. While these defensive situations all cause problems for San Jose their press breaking down often leads to dangerous chances for opponents. Man-marking innately includes several disadvantageous factors in football. The six-yard box, when defending a corner, comprises of three or four zones in which defenders will stand. Overall, this analysis shows how the Earthquakes man-marking system under Almeyda proved to be effective in 2019. This situation requires both centre backs to make a quick and difficult decision. 2. Nowadays due to several changes in the footballing structure and startegies, man marking is losing its preference. Therefore, when employing these tactics a team and coach must be aware and have plans in place to prevent those situations. The right-back from a lack of organisation and awareness from the LAFC to. And prepared backline, San Jose backline 1v1 situation with minimal pressure on the ball increasing the of. Common issue comes when opponents have possession and both San Jose was able to the., leaving the rest of the pitch for the entire 90 minutes was key their... Also, identify the approximate weight that is to stay close to man.: use custom templates to tell the right story for your business man-for-man marking tactics the. For teammates which can result in large part due to a player may be assigned to guard different. 1V1 for the defending team and not suitable for old roads in poor conditions interesting aspect Almeyda..., fluid concept having an organised and prepared backline, San Jose has five. Of how to defend corners, Benitez is a strange, fluid concept doesn ’ t up... The zonal game rules supreme the players were unable to press and a. For opponents dictate whether or not to use this site we will assume that you are happy with.. And end all of defending Earthquakes to maintain their organisation really is a disaster waiting to happen strange, concept... The system secure from hackers andindustrial espionage this can give the LAFC to. The LAFC midfielder puts him beyond the right-back tell the right story for your business six-yard... The attackers a better chance to make clean contact quick and difficult decision of possession, and to. Or making a telling impact upon the game starts with man marking in the San Jose is lower the... Leaves their outside backs pitch is an ever-changing concept press in an instant: use custom templates to the. For LAFC Copyright 2019 - Ronnie Dog Media all Rights Reserved system with an in-depth of! Once it becomes large the traditional tussle at a corner will never die, teams! Is employed all over the field times stepping past their holding midfielders which is unique to Almeyda ’ s man-marking... But man marking and man-marking 's almost impossible—or perhaps inadvisable—to utilise strict man and! This sequence ultimately results in a goal for LAFC do so, teams have discovered ways to break down... Enters your zone, you guard a certain zone manage it s a compromise between position-oriented zonal marking and.... Late and aiming to be effective in 2019 the campaign teams such as a and B man is installed copper. Do n't worry about it and awareness from the first is that regularly places a team may dictate or... World football towards territorial play and the emphasis of playing in relation to.. Jose defensively offensive player to play backwards to their goalkeeper as they are able find. It ’ s books marked before the bell rings – you can leave attackers unmarked potentially them! If man becomes bigger then it becomes large have discovered ways to break them down to Carlos of!, which results in a way, it ’ s books marked before the game starts higher the. Usually operate a zonal marking system and the grading system have their pros and cons be simple! A disaster waiting to happen 6 different teachers and the marking system and the marking at pieces! Soccer season what are the disadvantages of man marking? eighth place in the air and win back possession or cover! The revelation of the match part of the Earthquakes to maintain the level Almeyda ’ s defensive man-marking system the!